Thx Darren, same here, me too, I would have rejected my Idaho obs of Cassin’s Sparrow (Ada County, May 2013) in spite of prior experience elsewhere (see list below, all in expected range)……..
1st and 2nd state records need factual / unambiguous / documentation, eh? Photos and or recordings, with expected local veg in view…?
Next question is this.. do we delete our unexpected rarities or do we save them for future reference? Heidi kind of talked me into the latter…..
LA
·
·
·
Hello Larry Arnold (larnold47) | Preferences | Sign Out
« back
download (csv)
United States – Life Observations – Cassin’s Sparrow
Alphabetic Taxonomic
Location
S/P
Date
1
Cassin’s Sparrow
Nueces
US-TX
22 Nov 2002
2
Cassin’s Sparrow
Edwards
US-TX
23 Nov 2002
3
Cassin’s Sparrow
Santa Cruz
US-AZ
22 Mar 2003
4
Cassin’s Sparrow
Texas
US-TX
15 Apr 2003
5
Cassin’s Sparrow
Uvalde
US-TX
23 Apr 2003
6
Cassin’s Sparrow
Edwards
US-TX
20 May 2004
7
Cassin’s Sparrow
Granada area
US-CO
27 Apr 2005
8
Cassin’s Sparrow
Texas
US-TX
10 Apr 2006
9
Cassin’s Sparrow
Cochise
US-AZ
16 Apr 2006
10
Cassin’s Sparrow 2
ditch around Cedar H Cemetery
US-CO
07 Jul 2011
11
Cassin’s Sparrow
Neenoshe Reservoir
US-CO
30 Jul 2011
12
Cassin’s Sparrow
county roads off of 385
US-CO
30 Jul 2011
13
Cassin’s Sparrow
Pawnee National Grassland–Murphy’s Pasture area & auto tour stops 2 & 3
US-CO
01 Aug 2011
14
Cassin’s Sparrow 2
Holbrook Reservoir
US-CO
07 Jun 2012
15
Cassin’s Sparrow
Baca County – CR10
US-CO
09 Jun 2012
16
Cassin’s Sparrow
Bac County – M Rd
US-CO
09 Jun 2012
17
Cassin’s Sparrow
Bonny Reservoir–State Wildlife Area–south side of lake
US-CO
10 Jun 2012
18
Cassin’s Sparrow 1
Holyoke Cemetery
US-CO
01 Sep 2012
19
Cassin’s Sparrow 1
Ada – Joplin Rd
US-ID
19 May 2013
From: Darren Clark [mailto:darrenclarkbird@gmail.com]
Sent: Monday, June 26, 2017 8:00 PM
To: Larry Arnold
Cc: Jay Carlisle; ible@yahoogroups.com
Subject: Re: [IBLE] from Inland NW listserv: Probable Alder Flycatcher in Coolin (Priest Lake)
I feel good about mine, but I didn’t get a recording or photo. If I was voting I would have rejected it. A recording should be easy enough. My bird just shut up after it sung a couple of times.
Darren
Sent from my iPhone
On Jun 26, 2017, at 1:09 PM, ‘Larry Arnold’ larnold47@cableone.net [ible] wrote:
Interesting…….. previous reports by Darren and Cliff are believable to me, and IBRC should maybe reconsider them?
Big picture is that they have been happening in other western states, last 10-20 yrs
Pls, let’s pay more attention to Big Picture migration events, maybe consider such factors, and be open minded, folks, ja?
Not impossible I say………
Crazy I’ve been discussing this sp with Cliff last day or so, and Darren how’d you feel about yours?
LA
From: ible@yahoogroups.com [mailto:ible@yahoogroups.com] On Behalf Of Jay Carlisle carlislejay@yahoo.com [ible]
Sent: Sunday, June 25, 2017 8:19 AM
To: ible@yahoogroups.com
Subject: [IBLE] from Inland NW listserv: Probable Alder Flycatcher in Coolin (Priest Lake)
Paul Sieracki just shared this on Facebook too … wish it wasn’t 8+ hours away ? Jay
Date: Sat Jun 24 2017 19:16 pm
From: gandrbond AT gmail.com
“This morning near our cabin at Coolin on Priest Lake, we encountered what almost certainly is an Alder Flycatcher. The call matched the call on our recording of Alder Flycatcher and could easily be differentiated from the Willow Flycatchers calling nearby. We then played the Alder Flycatcher call and the bird immediately flew right at us and lit on a branch so I could photograph it. The bird has a definite thin eye ring, definitely more of an eye ring than I have ever seen on a Willow Flycatcher and I am convinced it is an Alder Flycatcher. We walk this road every day I this is the first time we have heard this bird. On this 3/4 mile road this spring we have now identified 6 Empids, which includes a Least Flycatcher that has been calling daily for the last week. As best I can tell there are no records of Alder Flycatcher for the state of Idaho.
Bob Bond”